Senate Republicans Block IVF Legislation for the Second Time

Senate Republicans blocked a Democratic bill aimed at protecting and ensuring nationwide access to in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatments on Tuesday, September 17th. This marks the second time the legislation has failed to advance, with a vote of 51-44 falling short of the 60 votes needed to proceed. The issue has become a focal point in the run-up to the November elections, as Democrats seek to highlight differences with Republicans on reproductive rights.

The proposed bill, sponsored by Senator Tammy Duckworth, aimed to establish a statutory right for individuals to access IVF treatments, empower the Justice Department to enforce the law, and require both private and public health insurers to cover IVF procedures. Despite some Republicans, such as Alaska’s Lisa Murkowski and Maine’s Susan Collins, supporting the measure, the majority of GOP members rejected it, calling it unnecessary and politically motivated.

Senator Duckworth criticized Republican claims that they support IVF, pointing out that recent laws, such as Alabama’s, which recognize discarded embryos as children, threaten access to IVF. She argued that while former President Donald Trump expressed support for federal coverage of IVF, such support is meaningless if state laws prohibit the procedure, calling his position “a red herring.”

Florida Senator Rick Scott, who opposed the bill, proposed expanding health savings accounts to help cover IVF costs. However, Duckworth contended that Scott’s support for the personhood of fertilized eggs directly conflicts with a genuine endorsement of IVF treatments. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer also attempted to link Republican opposition to the Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025, which includes restrictions on reproductive healthcare.

This rejection follows a pattern: Republicans previously blocked related legislation in February and June. Despite a statement by all 49 Senate Republicans expressing support for IVF access, Democrats argue that GOP actions contradict their rhetoric. As the debate continues, reproductive rights advocates and political observers are closely watching how this issue will shape the 2024 election campaigns.